Why Do I Eat More After Saying “I’ll Start a Diet Anyway”?

Yasemin Soysal

Why do I eat more after saying “I’ll start a diet anyway”? Thinking about going on a diet and putting off changing your eating habits with the thought “I’ll start a diet anyway” makes many people eat more. Psychological factors lie at the root of this, and it can be looked at from many angles. There are several psychological reasons why people tend to eat more before starting a diet or during diet periods.

Why do I eat more after saying “I’ll start a diet anyway”? The psychological restriction effect

This is called the psychological restriction effect. With the idea of dieting, people may tend to forbid themselves certain foods. Forbidden foods become desirable, and this desire can grow before the diet even begins. With the subconscious thought that “what’s forbidden is more appealing”, a person may tend to eat more of these foods before the diet starts.

Why do I eat more after saying "I'll start a diet anyway"?

Is it the scarcity mindset or psychological restriction that makes us eat more? I think the answer is both. While dieting, we can talk about a scarcity mindset or feeling deprived. Foods we’re deprived of can create a stronger craving, but what about the appetite we feel before going on a diet? People who know by heart what they’ll go through during a diet don’t want to face that psychological struggle. They seem to think that if they eat more of these foods now, they’ll crave them less later, which is a huge misconception. Eating more before a diet sets off an even bigger vicious circle.

A legacy from our ancestors…

Why do I eat more after saying “I’ll start a diet anyway”? People may act on a scarcity mindset, a trait inherited from ancestors who lived where food was limited. During a diet, a subconscious fear can arise, and the body may try to store more energy to prepare for a possible future shortage. This can show up as a stronger-than-usual desire to eat.

Stress, emotional states and reward mechanisms can also play a role. People under stress may turn to food, which can trigger a desire to eat more. Likewise, reward mechanisms can kick in, because food perceived as a reward can be used to fill emotional gaps or cope with stress.

To build a psychologically healthy relationship with food, avoiding seeing food as a tool for reward or punishment and creating a healthy eating pattern can help you cope with the scarcity mindset.