Why Do I Keep Eating More Than My Body Needs?

Yasemin Soysal

Why do I eat more than I need? People usually eat more than they need for psychological reasons. Sometimes it comes from deprivation, sometimes from a scarcity mindset. When we fill a plate, we usually think not about what will do us good, but about what looks good, what smells good or what tasted delicious before.

So why do we want to eat more than we need? Science suggests this tendency depends on many different factors. You’ll see it’s about much more than a crazy permanent diet or perfect willpower.

Why do I eat more than I need?

Our genetic inheritance

First, part of our eating habits is genetic. Research suggests that genetic differences are one reason some people are more inclined to eat than others. This is part of why some of us have a weakness for tasty food. But genetics is only one part of a much bigger picture.

Our past and the subconscious

Second, our environment and especially our childhood experiences shape our eating habits. Families, usually with good intentions, tell their children “finish your plate” or “eat a little more”. But research suggests these practices can stop children from recognising their fullness signals and so lay the groundwork for eating more than they need.

Why do I eat more than I need? A simple illustration of a man with food in front of him, both arms raised, getting ready to eat with a fork in one hand and a spoon in the other. 'Why do I eat more than I need?' is written on the left, with the author's website www.yaseminsoysal.com in small type at the bottom centre

Studies on eating behaviour and obesity risk in toddlers and preschool children look at how children’s eating habits are often shaped by their parents and how these habits can raise the risk of obesity later in life. They suggest that parents telling children to “finish your plate” or “eat a little more” can stop children from recognising their internal fullness signals and lead them to eat more than they need.

In particular, parents forcing children to eat or constantly offering them food can lead children to ignore their own body’s hunger and fullness signals!

Other research on parents’ control over food has found that parental food-related control has an important effect on children’s eating behaviour. In particular, parents forcing children to eat or constantly offering them food can lead children to ignore their own body’s hunger and fullness signals.

These studies show that parents can influence their children’s eating behaviour and that this influence can have long-term consequences. These effects can play an important role in shaping children’s eating habits and overall health in adulthood.

You may never have thought about it, but this encourages us to neglect our own body’s messages and so go beyond our needs. It disrupts the rhythm of our appetite’s orchestra, and instead of dancing with us, it drags us into a random tango or waltz.

So what can we do? We can start to understand, hear and respect our own body’s voice better. When we manage this, eating becomes less of a struggle and more of a friendly dance. Most importantly, when we fill a plate, we start asking ourselves: “What do I really need?” and “Will this be good for my body?”