Why Does Our Mood Suffer When We’re on a Diet?

Yasemin Soysal

To the question “Why does our mood suffer when we’re on a diet?” we can answer: because of the psychological and physiological resistance we build up. The ups and downs your body goes through on a diet can upset your mood in the moment. Years of dieting can damage your body image and your relationship with food, and over time this can make psychological problems lasting.

Why does our mood suffer on a diet? What is the hidden danger of diets?

What is the hidden danger of diets? When you think about a fresh start with a diet, you usually have a goal in mind. Maybe a dress size, a target weight, or simply feeling healthier. But the hidden truth of diets is that they often make these goals impossible to reach. The process can even lead you down a more destructive path.

Why does our mood suffer on a diet? Diets usually impose a short-term, rigid, rule-based lifestyle. But these restrictions often make you feel like a failure. As a result, your self-confidence suffers and your motivation drops (Foster et al., 1997). The initial enthusiasm and hope give way to disappointment and helplessness.

Can diets increase eating disorders?

Can diets increase eating disorders? Unfortunately, yes! Dieting often, creating strict diets on your own and watching the clock while you’re hungry can significantly increase your risk of eating disorders. A weight-loss process that starts with sudden, restrictive diets can get out of control after a while and turn into a serious eating disorder (Stice et al., 2009). 

It’s important to remember that teenagers and young adults are the most vulnerable groups, because personality and body image change rapidly at these ages.

Why does our mood suffer on a diet? Image of a happy woman with curly red hair eating a hamburger, with 'Why does our mood suffer on a diet?' in large type at the top and 'subconscious, weight-loss articles' just below

Looking at “Why does our mood suffer on a diet?” psychologically, sticking to a diet programme unfortunately often leads to stress and anxiety. Because every food and drink you have to say “no” to is perceived as a potential loss, and this can harm your overall mental health (Papies et al., 2016).

After a while, the idea of dieting can become an enemy that triggers symptoms of depression and anxiety.

Just imagine: you’d constantly find yourself saying “no” to things. In fact, the problem is the intensity of the unnecessary messages saying, “Yes, I want to eat this.” The body can send such messages even when it’s full. In fact, you’re the one triggering them. If you can’t notice why you’re sending these messages, you’ll keep living with the stress of having to say “no” to your own “I’d better eat this” message.

What you need to solve here is why your body sends a “you should eat this” message for no reason. Dieting instead of finding the cause of that false message is like taking a painkiller instead of solving the problem behind the pain. Because the pain itself isn’t the problem. If you find what’s causing the pain, the pain will go away anyway. But the painkiller can make things worse, just like a diet. Because when it wears off, the pain is even stronger since the problem wasn’t solved. After a diet has upset your mood, your eating episodes can become worse than they were before the diet.

Remember that some people feel the need to eat more under stress. In this process, a diet you may have started to feel better can, after a while, become an enemy that triggers symptoms of depression and anxiety. A feeling that you can’t control your willpower also deals a blow to your self-esteem. And when you notice you’re moving further away from your dreams rather than closer, it’s only a matter of time before you lose hope.

When you ask “Why does our mood suffer on a diet?”, the hidden danger of diets begins exactly here. It’s important to think twice before setting out on a journey that could put your mental health at risk. Instead, turning to sustainable options suited to your own lifestyle, such as healthy eating habits and regular physical activity, is a healthier choice. You need to find what’s causing your eating problems; otherwise it’s only a matter of time before you keep dieting and stressing yourself out. If you’re struggling with your eating, talking to a doctor, dietitian or psychologist can help.

References:

  • Foster, G. D., Wadden, T. A., Swain, R. M., Stunkard, A. J., Platte, P., & Vogt, R. A. (1997). The Eating Inventory in obese women: clinical correlates and relationship to weight loss. International Journal of Obesity, 21(3), 210-216.
  • Stice, E., Marti, C. N., Shaw, H., & Jaconis, M. (2009). An 8-year longitudinal study of the natural history of threshold, subthreshold, and partial eating disorders from a community sample of adolescents. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 118(3), 587.
  • Papies, E. K., van Winckel, M., & Keesman, M. (2016). Food-specific decentering experiences are associated with reduced food cravings in meditators: A preliminary investigation. Mindfulness, 7(5), 1123-1131.