Why does the weight you lose on a diet come back? Because of poorly planned diets, forced weight-loss efforts and the toll losing weight takes on your mood, the weight you lose by dieting is very likely to return. Many people complain that the weight they lost comes back quickly. When weight lost with so much effort returns so fast, many people are bitterly disappointed. So why does the weight you lose on a diet come back?
Because of poorly planned diets, forced weight-loss efforts and the toll losing weight takes on your mood, the weight you lose by dieting is very likely to return.
In the middle of the night, in a kitchen filled with sadness, perhaps you’re the one meeting a tub of ice cream and a spoon. Sometimes for a wedding, sometimes before a holiday, maybe just to feel better about ourselves, we begin this weight-loss adventure. Strict discipline, rigid rules, a constant battle of willpower and, finally, the long-awaited moment of reaching the goal. But right after this moment of victory we often face an unexpected result: the weight comes back fast. Why does this happen? Here’s what science tells us.
If you’ve always been overweight and lost weight with a temporary diet, it’s not surprising when it comes back!
If you’ve always been overweight and lost weight with a temporary diet, it’s not surprising when it comes back. The brain accepts whatever is normal for you as normal. In terms of behaviour, it feels safer there. So if the weight lost on a diet doesn’t come with a change in behaviour, it’s only a matter of time before it returns. The weight was lost through external control by the diet. But it shouldn’t be like that. The thinking patterns in the brain need to change, and the weight should go naturally because your thoughts have changed. Overeating is a learned behaviour pattern.
Why does the weight you lose on a diet come back? Here are science’s striking answers.

Why does the weight you lose on a diet come back? Is it a hormonal war?
Dieting is like a war inside us. People on a diet often feel as if they’re fighting an enemy. When our body faces a shortage of food, its survival instinct kicks in and it activates a “protect the fat stores” plan. Hunger hormones change and the body tries to save energy, which sets the stage for weight to come back quickly, as if every kilo were looking forward to returning home… (Sumithran et al., 2011).
The brain’s games
Why does the weight you lose on a diet come back? The challenges of dieting aren’t only physical; you also have to solve a mental and emotional puzzle. Diets demand self-restriction and self-control, and this closes the brain’s doors to “eating freely”. When the diet ends, our mind is tired of self-control and goes looking for a “reward”. This search often ends in turning to junk food or sugary snacks and brings the weight back. Research shows that most dieters regain much of the weight they lose (Mann et al., 2007).
The psychological burden
The weight-loss journey pushes the body’s limits, and it’s a tough psychological experience too. Being in constant conflict with your own body affects your spirit and raises stress levels. Stress changes eating habits and often leads to overeating, which is one of the biggest reasons the weight returns (Adam & Epel, 2007).
The next time you start a weight-loss adventure and ask “Why does the weight you lose on a diet come back?”, consider treating yourself with a little more understanding. These physical and psychological obstacles help us see that losing weight isn’t a matter of “failure” or “success”. Respecting ourselves and understanding the needs of our body and mind is the key to real victory.
So how can we keep off the weight we lose on a diet?
In conclusion, diets are a complex process, and promises of rapid weight loss usually don’t lead to sustainable, healthy results. The real goal should be to change your thoughts and lifestyle and build a balanced, healthy eating pattern and a physical activity routine.
What you need to notice here is that because forced practices don’t create real change, the weight you lose will come back. You can keep off the weight you lose through deeper lifestyle changes. You can do it with (non-temporary) changes in your daily life. If you can make deep changes in many areas, from your plates to your clothes, from your morning routine to the kind of food you eat at the table, you can keep the weight off for much longer. If you can completely change your thoughts and the behaviours that cause the weight, then you’ll have solved your weight problem for good.
References:
- Sumithran, P. et al. (2011). Long-term persistence of hormonal adaptations to weight loss. N Engl J Med, 365(17), 1597-1604.
- Mann, T. et al. (2007). Medicare’s search for effective obesity treatments: diets are not the answer. American Psychologist, 62(3), 220-233.
- Adam, T. C., & Epel, E. S. (2007). Stress, eating and the reward system. Physiology & Behavior, 91(4), 449-458.